Ive had mixed results, and ended up with three different sealants over 5 bikes and a dozen wheelsets I use.
Rene Herse tires tires I used regular Orange seal…I need to top off or replace pretty every three months. Some tiny sidewall leakage on my Fleecer Ridge 55c tires when they sit for a bit, but will hold air for weeks, absolutely no leakage on my set of Manostash Ridge 44c tires, which makes me think the RH has been tinkering with the newer tire designs. I also use it one my gravel wheelsets, which currently consist also of Cont terra speed, Terrelo Dry, Pirelli Cinturato in H and M. The orange seal regular seals as good than Stan’s race, but last longer, and regular Stan’s will seal eventually but takes too long IMHO.
Conti GP5000 I have on both my road and my old fun and touring bike, and I use only Silca, which seals like none other, but I can see it not turn into a giant booger in 9-12 weeks, so I often remove the tire entirely, clean, and replace sealant…I have not had much luck with extender fluid. On side note, I have a new rear tire that has been leaking sidewall horrendously and doesn’t hold air overnight. I like silca with road tires because it seals quickly which is nice because of the higher pressures and I lose less sealant. We have lots of glass on the roads of broken car windows, broken bear bottles, and i get more road cuts than on the gravel.
With any bike tires I don’t ride a lot, like the endurance bike thats sitting on my indoor trainer, I use regular Stans, which last forever…seriously, I can get 6 months in some cases for adding some…that goes on maybe a set of wheels that I use only in the winter…I find it works ok…
I’ll never go back to tubes…I use to burn at least 3 a month…and nothing worse than changing a flat at 530am on the way to work.